cve.bz

CVE-2023-2088 redhat openstack: Expected Behavior Violation

6.5 mediumEPSS 1.2%

Medium (6.5) in redhat openstack. EPSS 1.2% estimated probability of exploitation activity in the next 30 days.

On this page
A flaw was found in OpenStack due to an inconsistency between Cinder and Nova. This issue can be triggered intentionally or by accident. A remote, authenticated attacker could exploit this vulnerability by detaching one of their volumes from Cinder. The highest impact is to confidentiality.

Severity

CVSS 3.1

6.5 medium
CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:H/I:N/A:N
EPSS
1.2% (unchanged from 1.2% a week ago; 1.2% 30 days ago) estimated probability of exploitation activity in the next 30 days; 69th percentile. Scored 2026-11-21. A forecast for this CVE across the internet, not for your own systems.
CISA's assessment (SSVC)
Exploitation: none · Automatable: no · Technical impact: partial, assessed 2025-01-24. From CISA's Vulnrichment in the CVE List: whether it is exploited, whether exploiting it can be automated, and how much control it gives.
CWE
CWE-440 Expected Behavior Violation
Published
Modified
NVD analysis
Analyzed, since modified
Record from
the NVD, synced

Fix and patched versions

Ask an AI about this CVE

Show the promptExplain CVE-2023-2088 for an engineer deciding whether to act. Use https://cve.bz/api/public/cves/CVE-2023-2088?via=ask-ai-copy and https://cve.bz/cve/CVE-2023-2088?via=ask-ai-copy as the source of truth: what is affected and which versions fix it, whether it is in CISA KEV, public exploits, and its EPSS (an internet-wide 30-day estimate of exploitation activity, not a forecast for my systems). If they give no fixed versions, use the CVE record https://cveawg.mitre.org/api/cve/CVE-2023-2088 or the vendor advisory, not third-party mirrors. Tell me how to check whether I am affected and how to verify a fix. Cite the sources and say where they are uncertain.

Opens a third-party assistant; its answer is its own, not cve.bz's. The prompt holds only this CVE's id and public links.

Affected

Linux distributions

DistributionReleasePackageFixed inAdvisory
Debian11cinder2:17.4.0-1~deb11u2DLA-3871-1
Debian12, 13, 14cinder2:21.1.0-3DEBIAN-CVE-2023-2088
Debian12, 13, 14nova2:26.1.0-4DEBIAN-CVE-2023-2088
Debian12, 13, 14python-glance-store4.1.0-4DEBIAN-CVE-2023-2088
Debian12, 13, 14python-os-brick4.1.0-3DEBIAN-CVE-2023-2088
Ubuntu16.04:LTS, 20.04:LTScinder, ironic, python-os-brick and 1 moreno fix listedUBUNTU-CVE-2023-2088 USN-6073-1 USN-6073-2 USN-6073-4
Ubuntu18.04:LTSironic, python-os-brick, python-glance-storeno fix listedUBUNTU-CVE-2023-2088
Ubuntu20.04:LTSnova2:21.2.4-0ubuntu2.3USN-6073-3
Ubuntu22.04:LTScinder2:20.2.0-0ubuntu1.1UBUNTU-CVE-2023-2088 USN-6073-1 USN-6241-1
Ubuntu22.04:LTSironic1:20.1.0-0ubuntu1.1UBUNTU-CVE-2023-2088 USN-6241-1
Ubuntu22.04:LTSnova3:25.1.1-0ubuntu1.1UBUNTU-CVE-2023-2088 USN-6073-3 USN-6241-1
Ubuntu22.04:LTSpython-glance-store3.0.0-0ubuntu1.3UBUNTU-CVE-2023-2088 USN-6073-2 USN-6241-1
Ubuntu22.04:LTSpython-os-brick5.2.2-0ubuntu1.2UBUNTU-CVE-2023-2088 USN-6073-4 USN-6241-1
UbuntuPro:16.04:LTS, Pro:20.04:LTSnovano fix listedUBUNTU-CVE-2023-2088
UbuntuPro:18.04:LTSnova, cinderno fix listedUBUNTU-CVE-2023-2088
Red Hatopenstack:13::el7python-glance-store, python2-glance-store0:0.23.1-0.20190916165255.cc7ecc1.el7ostRHSA-2023:3161
Red Hatopenstack:13::el7python-nova, openstack-nova, python-nova-tests and 13 more1:17.0.13-41.el7ostRHSA-2023:3161
Red Hatopenstack:13::el7python-os-brick, python2-os-brick0:2.3.9-12.el7ostRHSA-2023:3161
Red Hatopenstack:16.1::el8python-glance-store, python3-glance-store0:1.0.2-1.20220219073735.el8ostRHSA-2023:3156
Red Hatopenstack:16.1::el8python-os-brick, python3-os-brick0:2.10.5-1.20220112193420.634fb4a.el8ostRHSA-2023:3156
Red Hatopenstack:16.1::el8python3-cinder, openstack-cinder1:15.4.0-1.20230510003501.58f0e73.el8ostRHSA-2023:3156
Red Hatopenstack:16.1::el8python3-nova, openstack-nova, openstack-nova-api and 9 more1:20.4.1-1.20221005193232.el8ostRHSA-2023:3156
Red Hatopenstack:16.2::el8python-glance-store, python3-glance-store0:1.0.2-2.20230309124927.79e043a.el8ostRHSA-2023:3158
Red Hatopenstack:16.2::el8python-os-brick, python3-os-brick0:2.10.8-2.20220112064936.458bfad.el8ostRHSA-2023:3158
Red Hatopenstack:16.2::el8python3-cinder, openstack-cinder1:15.6.1-2.20230310075425.a19c1c9.el8ostRHSA-2023:3158
Red Hatopenstack:16.2::el8python3-nova, openstack-nova, openstack-nova-api and 9 more1:20.6.2-2.20230308185149.el8ostRHSA-2023:3158
Red Hatopenstack:16.2::el8tripleo-ansible0:0.8.1-2.20230309004941.el8ostRHSA-2023:3158
5 more for Red Hat in the JSON and on Red Hat's page.

From the distributions' data via OSV.dev: the Debian Security Tracker; Ubuntu Security Notices © Canonical Ltd., CC BY-SA 4.0; Red Hat Security Data © Red Hat, Inc., CC BY 4.0. Modified: reformatted and linked to CVE records. Credits. On the distributions' own pages: Debian · Ubuntu · Red Hat.

Red Hat

Red Hat rates this Critical.

Red Hat's statement

There are two ways this flaw can be triggered:

Intentional Type - A malicious user could use Cinder to detach their own volume. As Nova is not made aware of the situation, it might later grant the attacker access to a new volume of another user (later referred to as victim). As there are very little restrictions on how often this can be triggered and the victim might not have any way to identify if their volumes have been compromised, the impact to Cinder has been rated Critical.

Accident Type - This can occur if communication between Nova and Cinder is interrupted during a volume detachment process. A potential attacker seeking to exploit this type would need real-time access to logs and the ability to tamper with the private network. Due to these significant restrictions against triggering the vulnerability, components affected by this type are rated as Important.

Within Red Hat OpenStack Platform 13, it is not possible to eliminate the intentional type by code changes alone. Changes to policy and configuration are also required to restrict this vector. For details read the KCS article linked in the mitigation section.

Red Hat's mitigation

Red Hat OpenStack Platform 13: https://access.redhat.com/solutions/7012184

Red Hat OpenStack Platform 16 and newer: https://access.redhat.com/solutions/7012327

ProductPackageStateAdvisory
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 13.0 - ELSopenstack-nova-1:17.0.13-41.el7ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3161
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 13.0 - ELSpython-glance-store-0:0.23.1-0.20190916165255.cc7ecc1.el7ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3161
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 13.0 - ELSpython-os-brick-0:2.3.9-12.el7ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3161
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 13.0 (Queens) for RHEL 7.6 EUSopenstack-nova-1:17.0.13-41.el7ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3161
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 13.0 (Queens) for RHEL 7.6 EUSpython-glance-store-0:0.23.1-0.20190916165255.cc7ecc1.el7ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3161
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 13.0 (Queens) for RHEL 7.6 EUSpython-os-brick-0:2.3.9-12.el7ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3161
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 16.1openstack-cinder-1:15.4.0-1.20230510003501.58f0e73.el8ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3156
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 16.1openstack-nova-1:20.4.1-1.20221005193232.el8ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3156
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 16.1python-glance-store-0:1.0.2-1.20220219073735.el8ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3156
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 16.1python-os-brick-0:2.10.5-1.20220112193420.634fb4a.el8ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3156
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 16.2openstack-cinder-1:15.6.1-2.20230310075425.a19c1c9.el8ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3158
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 16.2openstack-nova-1:20.6.2-2.20230308185149.el8ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3158
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 16.2python-glance-store-0:1.0.2-2.20230309124927.79e043a.el8ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3158
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 16.2python-os-brick-0:2.10.8-2.20220112064936.458bfad.el8ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3158
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 16.2tripleo-ansible-0:0.8.1-2.20230309004941.el8ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3158
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 17.0openstack-cinder-1:18.2.1-0.20230509200451.1776695.el9ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3157
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 17.0openstack-nova-1:23.2.2-0.20221209190754.7074ac0.el9ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3157
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 17.0python-glance-store-0:2.5.1-0.20230509140449.5f1cee6.el9ostFixed 2023-05-17RHSA-2023:3157
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 13 (Queens)openstack-cinderWill not fix
Red Hat OpenStack Platform 16.1tripleo-ansibleNot affected
2 more in the JSON and on Red Hat's page.

Contains Red Hat Security Data © Red Hat, Inc., licensed under CC BY 4.0. Source: https://access.redhat.com/security/data. Modified: reformatted. Red Hat's page for CVE-2023-2088.

References

Check your stackJSON