cve.bz

CVE-2019-9513 (Resource Loop) Uncontrolled Resource Consumption

7.5 highEPSS 82%

Known as Resource Loop

High (7.5). EPSS 82% estimated probability of exploitation activity in the next 30 days.

On this page
Some HTTP/2 implementations are vulnerable to resource loops, potentially leading to a denial of service. The attacker creates multiple request streams and continually shuffles the priority of the streams in a way that causes substantial churn to the priority tree. This can consume excess CPU.

Severity

CVSS 3.1

7.5 high
CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:N/UI:N/S:U/C:N/I:N/A:H
EPSS
82% (unchanged from 82% a week ago; 82% 30 days ago) estimated probability of exploitation activity in the next 30 days; 100th percentile. Scored 2026-11-21. A forecast for this CVE across the internet, not for your own systems.
CWE
CWE-400 Uncontrolled Resource Consumption
Published
Modified
NVD analysis
Analyzed, since modified
Record from
the NVD, synced

Fix and patched versions

Ask an AI about this CVE

Show the promptExplain CVE-2019-9513 for an engineer deciding whether to act. Use https://cve.bz/api/public/cves/CVE-2019-9513?via=ask-ai-copy and https://cve.bz/cve/CVE-2019-9513?via=ask-ai-copy as the source of truth: what is affected and which versions fix it, whether it is in CISA KEV, public exploits, and its EPSS (an internet-wide 30-day estimate of exploitation activity, not a forecast for my systems). If they give no fixed versions, use the CVE record https://cveawg.mitre.org/api/cve/CVE-2019-9513 or the vendor advisory, not third-party mirrors. Tell me how to check whether I am affected and how to verify a fix. Cite the sources and say where they are uncertain.

Opens a third-party assistant; its answer is its own, not cve.bz's. The prompt holds only this CVE's id and public links.

Affected

Versions

From the NVD's CPE matches.

ProductAffected
apple:swiftniofrom 1.0.0 through 1.4.0
apache:traffic_serverfrom 6.0.0 through 6.2.3
apache:traffic_serverfrom 7.0.0 through 7.1.6
apache:traffic_serverfrom 8.0.0 through 8.0.3
canonical:ubuntu_linux16.04
canonical:ubuntu_linux18.04
canonical:ubuntu_linux19.04
debian:debian_linux9.0
debian:debian_linux10.0
fedoraproject:fedora30
synology:diskstation_manager6.2
fedoraproject:fedora29
opensuse:leap15.0
opensuse:leap15.1
redhat:jboss_core_services1.0
redhat:jboss_enterprise_application_platform7.2.0
redhat:jboss_enterprise_application_platform7.3.0
redhat:openshift_service_mesh1.0
redhat:quay3.0.0
redhat:software_collections1.0
redhat:enterprise_linux8.0
oracle:graalvm19.2.0
mcafee:web_gatewayfrom 7.7.2.0 before 7.7.2.24
mcafee:web_gatewayfrom 7.8.2.0 before 7.8.2.13
mcafee:web_gatewayfrom 8.1.0 before 8.2.0
f5:nginxfrom 1.9.5 before 1.16.1
f5:nginxfrom 1.17.0 through 1.17.2
oracle:enterprise_communications_broker3.1.0
oracle:enterprise_communications_broker3.2.0
nodejs:node.jsfrom 8.0.0 through 8.8.1
nodejs:node.jsfrom 8.9.0 before 8.16.1
nodejs:node.jsfrom 10.0.0 through 10.12.0
nodejs:node.jsfrom 10.13.0 before 10.16.3
nodejs:node.jsfrom 12.0.0 before 12.8.1

Linux distributions

DistributionReleasePackageFixed inAdvisory
Debian9nghttp21.18.1-1+deb9u1DSA-4511-1
Debian9nginx1.10.3-1+deb9u3DSA-4505-1
Debian10nghttp21.36.0-2+deb10u1DSA-4511-1
Debian10nginx1.14.2-2+deb10u1DSA-4505-1
Debian10nodejs10.19.0~dfsg1-1DSA-4669-1
Debian12, 13, 14nghttp21.39.2-1DEBIAN-CVE-2019-9513
Debian12, 13, 14nginx1.14.2-3DEBIAN-CVE-2019-9513
Debian12, 13, 14nodejs10.16.3~dfsg-1DEBIAN-CVE-2019-9513
Ubuntu16.04:LTSnginx1.10.3-0ubuntu0.16.04.4UBUNTU-CVE-2019-9513 USN-4099-1
Ubuntu18.04:LTSnginx1.14.0-0ubuntu1.4UBUNTU-CVE-2019-9513 USN-4099-1
Ubuntu20.04:LTSnghttp21.40.0-1ubuntu0.3USN-6754-1
Ubuntu22.04:LTSnghttp21.43.0-1ubuntu0.2USN-6754-1
UbuntuPro:14.04:LTS, Pro:16.04:LTS, Pro:18.04:LTSnodejsno fix listedUBUNTU-CVE-2019-9513
UbuntuPro:16.04:LTSnghttp21.7.1-1ubuntu0.1~esm2UBUNTU-CVE-2019-9513 USN-6754-1
UbuntuPro:18.04:LTSnghttp21.30.0-1ubuntu1+esm2UBUNTU-CVE-2019-9513 USN-6754-1
Red Hatenterprise_linux:8::appstreamnginx, nginx-mod-mail, nginx-debuginfo and 12 more1:1.14.1-9.module+el8.0.0+4108+af250afeRHSA-2019:2799
Red Hatenterprise_linux:8::appstreamnodejs, nodejs-docs, nodejs-devel and 3 more1:10.16.3-2.module+el8.0.0+4214+49953fdaRHSA-2019:2925
Red Hatenterprise_linux:8::appstreamnodejs-nodemon0:1.18.3-1.module+el8+2632+6c5111edRHSA-2019:2925
Red Hatenterprise_linux:8::appstreamnodejs-packaging0:17-3.module+el8+2873+aa7dfd9aRHSA-2019:2925
Red Hatenterprise_linux:8::appstreamnpm1:6.9.0-1.10.16.3.2.module+el8.0.0+4214+49953fdaRHSA-2019:2925
Red Hatenterprise_linux:8::baseosnghttp2, libnghttp2, nghttp2-debuginfo and 2 more0:1.33.0-1.el8_0.1RHSA-2019:2692
Red Hatenterprise_linux:8::crbnghttp2, libnghttp2-devel, nghttp2-debuginfo and 2 more0:1.33.0-1.el8_0.1RHSA-2019:2692
Red Hatjboss_core_services:1::el6jbcs-httpd24-apr, jbcs-httpd24-apr-devel, jbcs-httpd24-apr-debuginfo0:1.6.3-63.jbcs.el6RHSA-2019:3932
Red Hatjboss_core_services:1::el6jbcs-httpd24-apr-util, jbcs-httpd24-apr-util-nss, jbcs-httpd24-apr-util-ldap and 7 more0:1.6.1-48.jbcs.el6RHSA-2019:3932
Red Hatjboss_core_services:1::el6jbcs-httpd24-brotli, jbcs-httpd24-brotli-devel, jbcs-httpd24-brotli-debuginfo0:1.0.6-7.jbcs.el6RHSA-2019:3932
Red Hatjboss_core_services:1::el6jbcs-httpd24-curl, jbcs-httpd24-libcurl, jbcs-httpd24-libcurl-devel and 1 more0:7.64.1-14.jbcs.el6RHSA-2019:3932
Red Hatjboss_core_services:1::el6jbcs-httpd24-httpd, jbcs-httpd24-mod_ldap, jbcs-httpd24-httpd-devel and 5 more0:2.4.29-41.jbcs.el6RHSA-2019:2946
46 more for Red Hat in the JSON and on Red Hat's page.
SUSEHPE Helion OpenStack 8, Linux Enterprise Server 12 SP2-BCL, Linux Enterprise Server 12 SP2-LTSS and 13 morenghttp21.39.2-3.5.1SUSE-SU-2021:0932-1
SUSELinux Enterprise Module for Basesystem 15, Linux Enterprise Module for Basesystem 15 SP1nghttp21.39.2-3.3.1SUSE-SU-2019:2473-1
SUSELinux Enterprise Module for Server Applications 15nginx1.14.2-3.6.1SUSE-SU-2019:2559-1
SUSELinux Enterprise Module for Server Applications 15 SP1nginx1.14.2-6.3.1SUSE-SU-2019:2309-1
SUSELinux Enterprise Module for Web and Scripting 12nodejs1010.16.3-1.12.1SUSE-SU-2019:2254-1
SUSELinux Enterprise Module for Web and Scripting 12nodejs1212.13.0-1.3.1SUSE-SU-2020:0059-1
SUSELinux Enterprise Module for Web and Scripting 15, Linux Enterprise Module for Web and Scripting 15 SP1nodejs1010.16.3-1.12.1SUSE-SU-2019:2259-1
SUSELinux Enterprise Module for Web and Scripting 15, Linux Enterprise Module for Web and Scripting 15 SP1nodejs88.16.1-3.20.1SUSE-SU-2019:2260-1
SUSELinux Enterprise Server 11 SP4-LTSSMozillaFirefox68.2.0-78.51.4SUSE-SU-2019:14246-1
SUSELinux Enterprise Server 11 SP4-LTSSMozillaFirefox-branding-SLED68-21.9.8SUSE-SU-2019:14246-1
SUSELinux Enterprise Server 11 SP4-LTSSfirefox-atk2.26.1-2.8.4SUSE-SU-2019:14246-1
SUSELinux Enterprise Server 11 SP4-LTSSfirefox-cairo1.15.10-2.13.4SUSE-SU-2019:14246-1
9 more for SUSE in the JSON and on SUSE's page.
openSUSELeap 15.0nghttp2, nghttp2-python1.39.2-lp150.2.3.1openSUSE-SU-2019:2234-1
openSUSELeap 15.0nginx1.14.2-lp150.2.11.1openSUSE-SU-2019:2264-1
openSUSELeap 15.0, Leap 15.1nodejs1010.16.3-lp151.2.6.1openSUSE-SU-2019:2114-1
openSUSELeap 15.0, Leap 15.1nodejs88.16.1-lp151.2.6.1openSUSE-SU-2019:2115-1
openSUSELeap 15.1nghttp2, nghttp2-python1.39.2-lp151.3.3.1openSUSE-SU-2019:2232-1
openSUSELeap 15.1nginx1.14.2-lp151.4.3.1openSUSE-SU-2019:2120-1
AlmaLinux8nginx, nginx-mod-mail, nginx-filesystem and 5 more1:1.14.1-9.module_el8.3.0+2165+af250afe.almaALSA-2019:2799
AlmaLinux8nginx, nginx-mod-mail, nginx-mod-stream and 3 more1:1.14.1-9.module_el8.4.0+2221+af250afe.almaALSA-2019:2799
AlmaLinux8nginx, nginx-mod-mail, nginx-mod-stream and 3 more1:1.14.1-9.module_el8.5.0+34+dc1cfba5.almaALSA-2019:2799
AlmaLinux8nodejs-nodemon1.18.3-1.module_el8.3.0+2023+d2377ea3ALSA-2019:2925
AlmaLinux8nodejs-nodemon1.18.3-1.module_el8.3.0+2047+b07ac28eALSA-2019:2925
AlmaLinux8nodejs-packaging17-3.module_el8.3.0+2023+d2377ea3ALSA-2019:2925
AlmaLinux8nodejs-packaging17-3.module_el8.4.0+2224+b07ac28eALSA-2019:2925
AlmaLinux8nodejs-packaging17-3.module_el8.4.0+2521+c668cc9fALSA-2019:2925
Rocky Linux8nginx1:1.14.1-9.module+el8.4.0+542+81547229RLSA-2019:2799
Rocky Linux8nodejs-nodemon0:1.18.3-1.module+el8.3.0+101+f84c7154RLSA-2019:2925
Rocky Linux8nodejs-packaging0:17-3.module+el8.3.0+101+f84c7154RLSA-2019:2925
Alpinev3.7, v3.8, v3.10 and 14 morenghttp21.39.2-r0ALPINE-CVE-2019-9513
Alpinev3.8nginx1.14.1-r1ALPINE-CVE-2019-9513
Alpinev3.9nghttp21.35.1-r1ALPINE-CVE-2019-9513
Alpinev3.9nginx1.14.1-r2ALPINE-CVE-2019-9513
Alpinev3.9, v3.10, v3.11 and 13 morenodejs10.16.3-r0ALPINE-CVE-2019-9513
Alpinev3.10, v3.11, v3.12 and 12 morenginx1.16.1-r0ALPINE-CVE-2019-9513

From the distributions' data via OSV.dev: the Debian Security Tracker; Ubuntu Security Notices © Canonical Ltd., CC BY-SA 4.0; Red Hat Security Data © Red Hat, Inc., CC BY 4.0; SUSE security data, CC BY 4.0; AlmaLinux's OSV database, MIT; Rocky Linux's errata, BSD-3-Clause; the Alpine secdb, CC BY-SA 4.0. Modified: reformatted and linked to CVE records. Credits. On the distributions' own pages: Debian · Ubuntu · Red Hat · SUSE · openSUSE · Alpine.

Red Hat

Red Hat rates this Important.

Red Hat's statement

This flaw has no available mitigation for packages nghttp2 and nodejs. Both packages will be updated once the available fixes are released for Red Hat Enterprise Linux and Red Hat Software Collections.

The nodejs RPM shipped in OpenShift Container Platform 3.9 and 3.10 is not affected by this flaw as it does not contain the vulnerable code.

Red Hat's mitigation

Red Hat Quay 3.0 uses Nginx 1.12 from Red Hat Software Collections. It will be updated once a fixed is released for Software Collections. In the meantime users of Quay can disable http/2 support in Nginx by following these instructions:

1. Copy the Nginx configuration from the quay container to the host

$ docker cp 3aadf1421ba3:/quay-registry/conf/nginx/ /mnt/quay/nginx

2. Edit the Nginx configuration, removing http/2 support

$ sed -i 's/http2 //g' /mnt/quay/nginx/nginx.conf

3. Restart Nginx with the new configuration mounted into the container, eg:

$ docker run --restart=always -p 443:8443 -p 80:8080 --sysctl net.core.somaxconn=4096 -v /mnt/quay/config:/conf/stack:Z -v /mnt/quay/storage:/datastorage -v /mnt/quay/nginx:/quay-registry/config/nginx:Z -d quay.io/redhat/quay:v3.0.3

ProductPackageStateAdvisory
JBoss Core Services on RHEL 6jbcs-httpd24-httpd-0:2.4.29-41.jbcs.el6Fixed 2019-10-01RHSA-2019:2946
JBoss Core Services on RHEL 6jbcs-httpd24-nghttp2-0:1.39.2-1.jbcs.el6Fixed 2019-10-01RHSA-2019:2946
JBoss Core Services on RHEL 6jbcs-httpd24-apr-0:1.6.3-63.jbcs.el6Fixed 2019-11-20RHSA-2019:3932
JBoss Core Services on RHEL 6jbcs-httpd24-apr-util-0:1.6.1-48.jbcs.el6Fixed 2019-11-20RHSA-2019:3932
JBoss Core Services on RHEL 6jbcs-httpd24-brotli-0:1.0.6-7.jbcs.el6Fixed 2019-11-20RHSA-2019:3932
JBoss Core Services on RHEL 6jbcs-httpd24-curl-0:7.64.1-14.jbcs.el6Fixed 2019-11-20RHSA-2019:3932
JBoss Core Services on RHEL 6jbcs-httpd24-httpd-0:2.4.37-33.jbcs.el6Fixed 2019-11-20RHSA-2019:3932
JBoss Core Services on RHEL 6jbcs-httpd24-jansson-0:2.11-20.jbcs.el6Fixed 2019-11-20RHSA-2019:3932
JBoss Core Services on RHEL 6jbcs-httpd24-mod_cluster-native-0:1.3.12-9.Final_redhat_2.jbcs.el6Fixed 2019-11-20RHSA-2019:3932
JBoss Core Services on RHEL 6jbcs-httpd24-mod_jk-0:1.2.46-22.redhat_1.jbcs.el6Fixed 2019-11-20RHSA-2019:3932
CloudForms Management Engine 5nginxNot affected
OpenShift Service Mesh Tech PreviewmaistraNot affected
Red Hat 3scale API Management Platform 2nginxWill not fix
Red Hat AMQ Broker 7jettyNot affected
Red Hat Ansible Tower 3nginxNot affected
Red Hat Enterprise Linux 8nginx:1.16/nginxNot affected
Red Hat JBoss Data Grid 7undertowNot affected
Red Hat JBoss Enterprise Application Platform 6jbosswebNot affected
Red Hat JBoss Enterprise Application Platform 7undertowNot affected
Red Hat JBoss Fuse 6undertowNot affected
84 more in the JSON and on Red Hat's page.

Contains Red Hat Security Data © Red Hat, Inc., licensed under CC BY 4.0. Source: https://access.redhat.com/security/data. Modified: reformatted. Red Hat's page for CVE-2019-9513.

Attack patterns (CAPEC)

  • CAPEC-147 XML Ping of the Death Likelihood: Low · Severity: Medium
  • CAPEC-227 Sustained Client Engagement
  • CAPEC-492 Regular Expression Exponential Blowup

The attack patterns MITRE's CAPEC relates to this record's weaknesses, as MITRE names them. Credits.

References

Check your stackJSON